The national government is central in policies to serve low-income and other needy persons. In these redistributive policies , those paying for a service in taxes are not usually those receiving the service. States cannot effectively provide redistributive benefits. It is impossible to stop people from moving away because they think they are paying too much in taxes for services.
Nor can states with generous benefits stop outsiders from moving there—a key reason why very few states enacted broad health care coverage [10] —and why President Obama pressed for and obtained a national program. The three levels of government also rely on different sources of taxation to fund their activities and policies. This enables it to shift funds away from the wealthier states e.
Taxes of local and state governments are more closely connected to services provided. Local governments depend mainly on property taxes, the more valuable the property the more people pay. State governments collect state income taxes but rely most on sales taxes gathered during presumably necessary or pleasurable consumer activity. Find more information about government budgets and taxes:.
As a result, governments often increase revenues on the sly, by lotteries, cigarette and alcohol taxes, toll roads, and sales taxes falling mostly on nonresidents like hotel taxes or surcharges on car rentals. A third reason federalism often works is because interest groups and professional associations focus simultaneously on a variety of governments at the national, state, and local levels.
With multiple points of entry, policy changes can occur in many ways. In bottom-up change, a problem is first identified and addressed, but not resolved at a local level. People, and often the media, then pressure state and national governments to become involved. Bottom-up change can also take place through an interest group calling on Congress for help.
In top-down change, breaking news events inspire simultaneous policy responses at various levels. Huge publicity for the beating that motorist Rodney King received from Los Angeles police officers propelled police brutality onto the agenda nationwide and inspired many state and local reforms.
Policy diffusion is a horizontal form of change. They can also make problems worse with ineffective or misdirected policies. These processes—bottom-up, top-down, and policy diffusion—are reinforced by the intergovernmental lobby.
State and local governments lobby the president and Congress. These associations trade information and pass resolutions to express common concerns to the national government. Such meetings are one-stop-shopping occasions for the news media to gauge nationwide trends in state and local government. The parties stand for different principles with regard to federalism.
Democrats prefer policies to be set by the national government. They opt for national standards for consistency across states and localities, often through attaching stringent conditions to the use of national funds. Principled distinctions often evaporate in practice. Both parties have been known to give priority to other principles over federalism and to pursue policy goals regardless of the impact on boundaries between national, state, and local governments.
So Republicans sometimes champion a national policy while Democrats look to the states. Create a personalised ads profile. Select personalised ads. Apply market research to generate audience insights. Measure content performance. Develop and improve products. List of Partners vendors. Share Flipboard Email. Issues The U. Legal System U. Foreign Policy U. Liberal Politics U. Robert Longley. History and Government Expert.
Robert Longley is a U. Facebook Facebook. Updated August 28, Featured Video. Cite this Article Format. Longley, Robert. Federalism and How It Works. Types of Federalism: Definition and Examples. The 10th Amendment: Text, Origins, and Meaning. What Are Inherent Powers? Definition and Examples.
Understanding States' Rights and the 10th Amendment. Constitution: Article I, Section 8. Current Justices of the U. In a federal system, it is agreed that a central government manages issues of common concern. These are issues like economic policy, foreign policy and national defence.
It also guarantees some level of autonomy to specific territorial units - which might be states, regions, or provinces. These territorial units usually have autonomy over identity issues, like language and culture, regional economic development, infrastructure and public services. Federalism is a practical way of dealing with some - but not all - of the tough challenges and problems of coexistence that exist in diverse societies. What can it do for the people, but also what are its limitations?
First, federalism can give people meaningful powers to choose policies that suit their specific needs in their own territories. This might be based on identity. For example, they can choose what language they are to be educated in and to have news broadcast in that language. It might be control of local economic development - promoting local industries like agriculture, tourism and trade - or management of natural resources such as water, minerals and forests.
It might also be because the country is very large. This makes it hard to govern the entire country from the capital city. For example, Australia has no major cultural differences between states, but it would be hard to govern such a large territory from one location.
Second, federalism disperses access to power, wealth and resources more widely to different territorial groups. It may help promote both peace and stability by giving local people a stake in the system.
It might also encourage better governance, with more equal economic development. Third, by satisfying demands for recognition, autonomy and resources, federalism might help ease political tensions and prevent secession. It might help countries that would otherwise fall apart, to hold together. Fourth, federalism is a safeguard against abuses of power.
0コメント